spudthedestroyer wrote:My list, as i said isn't my top 15 because I'd need a while to sit down and compile it. We probably need to compile all the movies then pick the best 15 from the list.
not my call, but I think it will produce more "true" results.
Maybe we should outright ban films made in the last ten years; there's a fuzzy logic applied to new movies that they are the best thing ever
that's a bit dangerous, I think. I understand the rationale, but everyone prefers their favorite movies in large part because of who they were at the time and how that movie worked at that time rather than any absolute criterion for greatness.
*my bad, I thought it was critically best OR favorite. I would rejig my list a bit just on that. serenity, however, is on there primarily for critical anyway. I really dig the reaver plot and the civilized/savage themes.
Life ducks, and you sigh.